Bg-img

Best 10 Toy Stores in New York City

  • Home
  • >
  • Insights, Tips & News – Stay Updated
Blog Image
Share Now
  • Admin
  • Mar 24, 2025
  • Retail & Shopping

Best 10 Toy Stores in New York City

Best Of Top 10 Toy Stores in New York City

New York City is a paradise for toy lovers, offering an incredible variety of stores filled with games, action figures, plush toys, and collectibles. Whether you are searching for educational toys, classic stuffed animals, or the latest action figures, NYC has it all. From iconic flagship stores to hidden gems, we explore the Top 10 toy stores in New York City that every shopper should visit.

The Best Toy Stores in NYC for Kids and Collectors

Shopping for toys in NYC is a magical experience, with stores catering to children, parents, and collectors alike. Whether you're visiting one of the Luxury Shopping New York destinations or Local Farmers Market NYC, there's a good chance you'll stumble upon a store filled with fascinating toys.

Best Toy Stores in New York

FAO Schwarz – A Legendary Toy Haven

Located at Rockefeller Plaza, FAO Schwarz is one of the most famous toy stores in the world. Established in 1862, this store offers an incredible selection of plush toys, dolls, and interactive play stations. The massive floor piano featured in the movie Big is a must-try for visitors.

The LEGO Store – A Dream for Builders

Situated in the heart of Fifth Avenue, The LEGO Store is perfect for kids and adults alike. With giant LEGO sculptures, interactive displays, and NYC-themed LEGO sets, it’s an exciting destination for builders of all ages.

Camp – A Unique Interactive Toy Store

Camp is more than just a toy store; it's an interactive experience. Located in Flatiron, this store features rotating themes, interactive play areas, and exclusive toys, making it one of the most engaging toy stores NYC has to offer.

Toys "R" Us – A Classic Favorite

After making a return to NYC, Toys "R" Us now has a flagship store in Macy’s Herald Square. Known for its wide range of toys, including Sporting Goods stores NYC, board games, and electronics, it remains a top choice for parents.

Kidding Around – A Local Favorite

Located in Chelsea, Kidding Around is one of the best independent toy stores NYC has to offer. It provides a wide range of educational and classic toys, including puzzles, wooden toys, and unique plush animals.

Mary Arnold Toys – The Oldest Toy Store in NYC

Established in 1931, Mary Arnold Toys is the longest-running independent toy store in New York. Located on the Upper East Side, this store specializes in bookstores in New York, arts and crafts, and specialty toys for young children.

Nintendo NYC – A Gamer’s Paradise

Nintendo NYC in Rockefeller Center isn’t just for kids but also for video game enthusiasts. With exclusive merchandise, interactive displays, and limited-edition games, this store is perfect for those who love gaming.

American Girl Place – A Doll Lover’s Dream

Located on Fifth Avenue, American Girl Place is a must-visit for doll collectors. This store offers personalized dolls, accessories, and even a doll salon where kids can style their dolls' hair.

Lego Discovery Center – A Creative Wonderland

Situated in Westchester, this massive LEGO attraction features play areas, rides, and hands-on building experiences. It’s one of the best Toy stores NYC destinations for families looking for interactive fun.

Books of Wonder – A Book and Toy Combo

If you love books and toys, Books of Wonder in Union Square is an excellent choice. This independent bookstore specializes in children’s literature and also stocks a variety of plush toys and educational games.

FAQs 

  1. Where is the biggest toy store in NYC?

    • FAO Schwarz at Rockefeller Plaza is the largest and most famous toy store in NYC.

  2. Are there any famous toy stores in Times Square?

    • While Toys "R" Us had a giant store in Times Square, it now operates within Macy’s Herald Square.

  3. What is the best store for collectible action figures in NYC?

    • Midtown Comics and Forbidden Planet offer a fantastic selection of action figures and collectibles.

  4. Does FAO Schwarz have exclusive toys?

    • Yes, FAO Schwarz has exclusive plush toys, dolls, and limited-edition items.

  5. Which toy store in NYC has the best LEGO sets?

    • The LEGO Store on Fifth Avenue and LEGO Discovery Center offer the best LEGO sets and interactive displays.

  6. Where can I find educational toys in NYC?

    • Stores like Kidding Around and Mary Arnold Toys specialize in educational toys and games.

  7. Are there toy stores that offer custom-made toys?

    • Yes, FAO Schwarz and American Girl Place offer customization options for dolls and stuffed animals.

  8. Is there a toy store with an indoor play area?

    • Camp in Flatiron has an interactive play space along with its unique toy selection.

  9. Where can I buy retro and vintage toys in NYC?

    • Toy Tokyo and The Toy Museum of NY have a fantastic selection of vintage toys.

  10. Which NYC toy stores have a good selection of board games?

  • Kidding Around and The Compleat Strategist have great collections of board games for all ages.

  1. Are there toy stores in NYC that focus on handmade toys?

  • Yes, stores like Norman & Jules and local artisan markets specialize in handmade and wooden toys.

  1. What is the best toy store in NYC for plush toys?

  • FAO Schwarz and Disney Store offer some of the best plush toys and stuffed animals.

  1. Where can I find superhero action figures in NYC?

  • Midtown Comics and Forbidden Planet are excellent stores for superhero collectibles.

  1. Are there any specialty toy stores for toddlers?

  • Mary Arnold Toys and Kidding Around have fantastic selections for toddlers.

  1. Where can I buy educational science toys in NYC?

  • The Science, Industry, and Business Library offers kits, and The Learning Express carries educational science toys.

  1. Which NYC toy store is best for gaming consoles?

  • Nintendo NYC is the best place for gaming consoles and exclusive Nintendo merchandise.

  1. Where can I buy a gift for a child in NYC?

  • FAO Schwarz, American Girl Place, and Camp are great options for finding gifts.

  1. Is there a toy store that offers art and craft kits?

  • Kidding Around and Mary Arnold Toys have an extensive range of arts and crafts supplies.

  1. What is the best place to buy LEGOs in NYC?

  • The LEGO Store in Rockefeller Plaza and LEGO Discovery Center are top destinations.

  1. Are there any toy stores in NYC with gift-wrapping services?

  • Many independent stores like Kidding Around and FAO Schwarz offer gift-wrapping services.

 
 

0 Items
$0